Saturday, 16 February 2013

Diagnostic codes for GDPs in the UK

Diagnostic codes

Diagnostic codes are a means to record the findings and diagnoses for patients in a standardised manner and have been used in electronic health records for some time in the medical world. But dentistry has lagged behind with the only items being recorded those that are related to treatment.

Why record diagnostic codes? 


If we want to assess the suitability of patient management decisions - whether we are talking about diagnostic tests, prevention regimes, treatments or prognoses - we need to know what the decisions relate to.

Say a dentist writes in their notes that they have prescribed Amoxicillin 500mg TDS for 5 days and writes nothing else. We have no idea whether this is the appropriate way to manage whatever it was the patient walked in with. We need to know what diagnosis led to this prescription. Some dentists prescribe only when there is a risk of spreading infection or when incision and drainage of an abscess is impossible. Others prescribe when a patient has an irreversible pulpitis without opening the pulp chamber despite the lack of evidence to support this approach.

So we generally expect that a dentist will record a presenting complaint, the results of any investigations and their diagnosis. This is better note keeping but because we each come up with different terms and have different short hand ways of writing our notes it can be difficult to gather comparable information from many dentists.

So diagnostic codes have developed as a means to standardise the diagnoses given by clinicians to a limited set of terms. International organisations have come together to map these terms in different languages too, so that international comparisons can be made.

So what?



Well, it means that one can audit the practice of many hundreds of clinicians using computer records rather than wading through text trying to understand what people have done. QResearch in the UK now gathers data from 600 general medical practices in the UK, anonymises the data and allows researchers to assess, for example, the number of patients being prescribed the best medication for a given condition. This is possible because all the practices use the same set of terms for their diagnoses and for the treatment they prescribe. My understanding is that all the medical practice management systems use one terminology or another.

Unfortunately, though, the dental software companies in the UK don't seem to be doing this apart from EMIS Dental. (If I'm wrong please tell me as I'd love to know). A group of US dental schools are developing and using a terminology set and a recent conversation with a visiting American dental student suggests this is a routine of his practice.

International Health Terminology Standards Development OrganisationSNOMED CT is the international terminology that last year incorporated the American Dental Association's dental terminology. This presentation identifies some others being developed in the US. If you want to have a look at how SNOMED CT works there are various free browsers that let you see, such as SNOFLAKE. The terminology can be incorporated into any software with a licence which, I believe, is free in the UK as a member of the International Health Terminology Standards Development Organisation.

I find this quite exciting - if we could persuade dental software companies in the UK to use the codes. It would mean that our dental electronic health records could be used to easily audit our own practice and to potentially create a massive research data set from general dental practice. This in turn could form the basis of large studies to inform us about the prognosis of teeth, the success or otherwise of common interventions and the efficacy of prevention when delivered in primary dental care.

A call to action


The NHS Connecting for health will require SNOMED CT to be part of any electronic health record used in NHS practice. I believe we should go further in dentistry as much of our work is being conducted outside of the NHS. So I call on UK dentists to begin pestering software developers to incorporate SNOMED CT into their systems and allow general dental practitioners to contribute not only to their own practice improvement but to more meaningful research conducted in primary dental care.


2 comments:

  1. Very nice post, thanks for sharing the information. Keep up the good work.

    peabody teeth cleaning

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi there! great stuff, glad to drop by your page and found these very interesting and informative. Thanks for sharing, keep it up!

    dentist wakefield ma

    ReplyDelete